The story of St. Andrew's Episcopal Church begins in November of 1832, when neighbors met at the house of Jacob Ludwig to discuss formation of a new church in the area. At least some of those attending the meeting at Ludwig's house wanted to form a union church, bringing together Lutherans, Baptists, and other Christians in one congregation. Others wanted an Episcopalian church, and under the influence of the Rev. Levi Bull, an Episcopalian evangelist and church builder, an Episcopal congregation formed.

In short order, the new congregation received a gift of land, raised sufficient funds to erect a building, called a rector, and perhaps influenced by the name of an earlier church of unknown denomination that stood on the same land, opened the present St. Andrew's Church just a year after that first meeting. The first rector, the Rev. Cyrus Jacobs, was both a brother-in-law and evangelical ally of Levi Bull, and within one year baptized 37 adults and seven infants.

After Jacobs returned to Virginia in 1836, however, St. Andrew's began to decline. From time to time, St. Andrew's shared rectors with neighboring Episcopal churches; but finally, at the opening of the Civil War, the church was closed after the rector resigned to return to Virginia and serve with the Confederacy.

Reopened in 1866, the church soon closed again, and was periodically reopened under the leadership of rectors from other churches. In 1920, the church was closed again, apparently forever.  Shortly thereafter, the corporation was dissolved and the property turned over to the Diocese of Pennsylvania.

Protected by its isolation and by a small endowment for its maintenance, the church building survived. Then, in 1950, a group of area residents petitioned the bishop to reopen the church. Even though only four of this early group were Episcopalians, 15 families pledged $100 apiece, and with the help of the Reverend Crosswell McBee, retired rector of St. David's Church in Radnor, and the support of Owen J. Roberts, retired Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court, St. Andrew's was reopened, reincorporated, and restored. The windows, the box pews, the oil lamps, the Caribbean tray ceiling and theater-style sloping floor were intact, and soon the church was filled again with worship and fellowship.

In 1953, the Rev. Kenneth C. Werner began service that was to last more than 30 years. Under his care, St. Andrew's flourished, with membership rising from 1950's four communicants to 210 in 1956. In this period, the physical plant was expanded twice, a new rectory was built, and an active youth group was organized.

When the Rev. Werner retired in 1984, the Rev. Dr. Joseph T. Rivers was chosen to replace him. Arriving in 1985, Father Rivers expanded use of the new prayer book, introduced the new hymnal to St. Andrew's, increased the frequency of Eucharistic celebration and added childrens' sermons. In November 1995, the Rev. Elsa Hale Mintz arrived after answering St. Andrew's call to become rector. Like many of her predecessors, Rev. Mintz came to us from Virginia. With a thorough knowledge of St. Andrew's needs and desires, she began to put in place the foundation for the future parishioners outlined in their responses to the parish survey.

In summary, it appears that St. Andrew's has been something of a Phoenix among churches. It has strengthened and struggled, been shuttered and resurrected, and is today looking to a bright future built on a historic past.